After finishing the 50 Shades series, I was left with a lot of questions (what the F*CK did I just read?!) and a general sense of relief that it was over.
So let me get this straight, readers are supposed to believe that Anastasia Steele, a 21-year-old virgin who has a vocabulary unheard of in a young twenty-something, meets Christian Grey, a 26-year-old tycoon who has the personality of a 45-year-old misogynistic divorced man and “kinky fuckery” ensues? Right.
I take more of an issue with the general plot than the sex scenes, although how many times can you read the foreplay of the sex scenes and know that Miss Steele is going to say “oh my”, Mr. Grey is going to say “oh, Ana” AND they finish at the EXACT. SAME. TIME. Yeah, because that happens in real life.
Yes, I understand that the whole concept of these novels was originally supposed to be Twilight Fan Fiction. (For anyone unfamiliar with fan fiction: it’s an author’s erotic take on a show/movie/celebrity etc.) But now I have two fictional characters to add to my “dislike” list: Isabella Swan and Anastasia Steele. For God’s sakes, it’s 2012, female authors should not be making their young female characters so needy, naïve, and just plain oblivious.
Examples:
Anastasia Steele: “I just don’t understand what he could possibly see in me.” Well, clearly something if he has spent an obscene amount of money on you AND is propositioning you to be his sexual submissive.
Anastasia Steele: “Make love to me.” (FYI: This is her first-time request)
Christian Grey: “I don’t make love, I fuck hard.”
Now I don’t know about you, but if a guy said that to me, or ANY other girl on the eve of her first time, I would roll my eyes, put my clothes on, politely close the door behind me and then key his car. But no, she’s totally cool with it and we have to read her inner dialogue that is like “oh my” and “he touched me down there”, and, my favourite, “my inner goddess is doing backflips around the arena.” Yeah, well mine just threw up in her mouth.
Actually compared to the rest of the dull dialogue, the sex scenes aren’t so bad. Ana and Christian never refer to each other as anything but their first names or last names. How annoying would it be if someone began every sentence with your name? “Ashley, do you want some orange juice?” “Miss Guay, pass the salt please.” If someone uses my name in a sentence, it usually means I’m in trouble.
There’s also the annoying use of the word “shall”. “Shall we go to dinner?” “Shall I fetch it for you?’ Who talks like this? WHO? Yeah, no one.
Then there is the character of Ana Steele herself. I don’t think E.L. James does a good job of describing her because all I really know is she is a brunette with blue eyes who doesn’t think much of herself and who’s always trying to save everyone. Case in Point: In the third book, she gets a ransom call (Yeah, there is some action other than that going on with body parts) and the caller warns her not to tell anyone or he’ll kill her sister-in-law. Okay, so she’s described as about 5”4 maybe weighing 110lbs and for some reason thinks it would be a good idea to go up against the killer herself, oh and tell her husband she is leaving him in an effort to “get him off the scent”. Had she been super feisty, confident and independent from the get-go, I might have bought it but these were the scenes I had to push myself through just so I could say I finished the book.
Another scene that cemented my feelings for her was in the ending of the first book. She wants to show him that she can deal with his “50 shades of fucked-upness” so she lets him beat her ass with a cane (could have been a belt or a crop). She KNOWS it’s going to hurt, he TELLS her it’s going to hurt (and he’s spanked her before so I mean that pretty much should have told her she didn’t have the pain threshold to be caned) and wouldn’t you know it, it hurts. WEIRD. She goes all “You’re fucked up” (umm yeah) on him and leaves. The part that bothers me, you knew all this, so either suck it up and take it or suggest something that may not hurt as much? I don’t know?
Being an independent Twenty-Something, I would have been way more into the books if Ana was the dominant. If she would have played hard-to-get with Christian Grey it could have made for some much better built-up sex scenes. If she would have forgone marriage and said “I love you but I can’t marry you, I’m 22 and want to see the world first,” it might have made the third book more interesting. I mean, really, who gets married at 22? Yeah, exactly. At least Katniss in The Hunger Games gave both Gale and Peeta a good chase and didn’t place them anywhere near the top of her priorities.
I mean good for E.L. James for coming up with a way to make millions. Seriously, I applaud her. But if you have read these books and can’t honestly say one bad thing about them, I would be curious to know what your other reading material looks like.